Landlords want NYC to pay them for neighbors’ scaffolding that plagues sidewalks in endless ‘Whack-a-mole’

By Mia Spero

Landlords are tired of how New York City handles the encroachment of sidewalk sheds from neighboring buildings onto their property. These monstrosities are made of metal scaffolding and tarps, appearing like cages extending over sidewalks. Many sheds stay in place for years, deter tenants, block light, and invite pests, all while intruding onto private property without permission. It is time for New York City to pay up. Four landlords are now suing City Hall in a class-action lawsuit arguing that their Fifth Amendment rights are being violated. They claim that the constitution protects them from the city, as their property is subjected to this encroachment, without offering compensation. The lawsuit remains in progress, but the city has taken the initiative to shorten permit durations for sheds and increase penalties for landlords delaying the necessary repairs. 

Read more about the author: Mia Spero

Email: mrs10078@nyu.edu